First of all. Where’s Wanda?!? This pizza is amazing. I suggest to add a few toppings to the pizza behind the glass, only 50¢ per. The upmost friend staff. Kai is amazing and deserves a tip just for his great conversation while your pizza is cooking. Best quick pizza place around
Aravind V
-
July 24, 2023
Had take out. Did not feel that the pizza was worth the price. Average at best. Also, even after the transaction was completed online, they still ask you to sign a paper copy at the store. This is just for adding the tips. While I understand why they do it, it is much better off including it in the online portal itself so that it is all one transaction.
Shoshana Zerbock
-
January 02, 2023
My friend and I ordered a 24" half cheese half pepperoni pizza. We were excited for the novelty of such a large pizza, but alas.. our hopes were dashed when we got home and found short, dark, curly hairs baked into the cheese. We called to get a refund, and the person on the phone was incredibly unapologetic and rude. When we returned to the store to get the cash refund, we noticed the man making pizzas had a bushy beard, and wasn't wearing a hairnet over his beard. I will never go back, and suggest that you avoid this place if you like your food hair-free.
Todd Shackelford
-
September 28, 2020
I had the 2 slice and a drink lunch special, which was a very good deal and was pleasantly surprised at the size of the slices. They are huge! I have had a lot of actual NYC pizza in NYC and this was very authentic and quite tasty. Service was friendly and quick. I will definitely come back and I definitely recommend Cosmo's for an authentic NY pie.
ZZ P Johns
-
June 16, 2022
Ordered pizza at 5:48 pm. Did not receive pizza until 7:30 pm. Had to call twice to get it delivered. Then couldn't eat the $8 salad, because it was full of black, slimy greens. Pictures below. I wrote about this on their Facebook page last night, and they have since deleted it.
First of all. Where’s Wanda?!? This pizza is amazing. I suggest to add a few toppings to the pizza behind the glass, only 50¢ per. The upmost friend staff. Kai is amazing and deserves a tip just for his great conversation while your pizza is cooking. Best quick pizza place around
Had take out. Did not feel that the pizza was worth the price. Average at best. Also, even after the transaction was completed online, they still ask you to sign a paper copy at the store. This is just for adding the tips. While I understand why they do it, it is much better off including it in the online portal itself so that it is all one transaction.
My friend and I ordered a 24" half cheese half pepperoni pizza. We were excited for the novelty of such a large pizza, but alas.. our hopes were dashed when we got home and found short, dark, curly hairs baked into the cheese. We called to get a refund, and the person on the phone was incredibly unapologetic and rude. When we returned to the store to get the cash refund, we noticed the man making pizzas had a bushy beard, and wasn't wearing a hairnet over his beard. I will never go back, and suggest that you avoid this place if you like your food hair-free.
I had the 2 slice and a drink lunch special, which was a very good deal and was pleasantly surprised at the size of the slices. They are huge! I have had a lot of actual NYC pizza in NYC and this was very authentic and quite tasty. Service was friendly and quick. I will definitely come back and I definitely recommend Cosmo's for an authentic NY pie.
Ordered pizza at 5:48 pm. Did not receive pizza until 7:30 pm. Had to call twice to get it delivered. Then couldn't eat the $8 salad, because it was full of black, slimy greens. Pictures below. I wrote about this on their Facebook page last night, and they have since deleted it.